Stagii pe Bune – what a joke!

Posted by on iunie 18, 2007
Fără categorie

Stagii Pe Bune is a project started by former students from my university. The idea is brilliant: to offer students with a way to accumulate work experience IN ROMANIA during the summer in internships in some of the best known IT&C companies in the country. The site is quite well-designed (despite a few privacy issues) and easy to use.

The funny (or sad, depending on the number of options you have) part starts when you are contacted by get to deal with the companies. I personally applied to 5 internships, I’ve been called to 4 interviews and went to two of them (my apologies to the Adobe Romania team, I would have really liked to know you 🙂 ).

One of the companies didn’t even look at the position I applied for, they just made a big pool of all the CVs then started pulling from the stack 🙂 It was a matter of luck to get where you wanted, and most of us didn’t. I even ended up in a different division. However, I was the only one to clearly tell them the I was disappointed with the offer and I would prefer to work in the division I applied for. They told me that they’ll forward my CV and will get back to me if I was to pass a second test. The test passed and I had lost all hope. Two weeks later, they call to inform me that their employees decided the first test was enough and they had a position for me. All of my colleagues have a similar story. I wonder if they do the same with the CVs received for ordinary openings (which, btw, never appear 😛 ) or that’s a treatment reserved for students.

The second company had a much more developed company culture. You had to pass 3 interviews, each one weirder than the one before. At first we were impressed by the brand new company HQ downtown, but for the second interview I had to drive all the way to the middle of nowhere, in the „Romanian Silicon Valley” (aka Pipera). There was of course no parking space for the visitors and there was a huge difference between the inside and the outside of the building 🙂 But hey, if I were to have an interesting internship, the place would be less important, right?

So I went in and started the interview. By the middle of the discussion, I was making huge efforts not to laugh. I already knew that the discussion should be „by the (company) book”, but that was hilarious. A very young lady (younger than me, maybe?) was reading the questions and then tried to write down my answers in full, just like a little robot. The one question that I found the funniest was „Let’s do a little role-playing: Imagine that I [the HR person] am Daniel, your best friend. I kindly ask you to break your NDA and let me in your computer. How do you say no?” All that was quite all right, I was ready to put up with it so that I can get to the final discussion with the project manager. But when she told me I had to drive all the way back to Pipera the next morning in rush-hour for a 15 minutes talk with the „man in charge” (as she put it) and that it was my only chance, as he was leaving the country, I just said to myself „thanks, but I’ll pass”.

I know that all companies have their own way when recruiting new employees and the process can seem weird or difficult, but it seems to me that they don’t take the students they accept for internships too seriously. And that’s too bad, because today’s students are tomorrow’s employees and we will remember our experiences. So, a little piece of advice for my younger colleagues: if you feel strong enough to quit at the end of the summer, find yourself a real job. You’ll be better off both financially and professionally.

3 Comments to Stagii pe Bune – what a joke!

  • Cred ca ai exagerat un pic cu titlul…problema nu tine de stagiipebune (care mi se pare o initiativa foarte buna a lui Vlad de la IE -
    ci cu sistemul romanesc de HR.

    Eu am vazut o firma de recrutare care indiferent ce fel de web developer angaja, dadea un test grila de asp.Atat aveau, aia dadeau, nu conta ca tu ai in cv php sau jsp.
    Le-am zis „credeti ca daca stiam asp, nu treceam in cv”… au ridicat din umeri.

    Cred ca in HR am intalnit cei mai incompetenti angajati posibili (si asta in majoritatea firmelor):(
    Deci cred ca s-ar potrivi mai bine interviuri in RO cu HR-ul – what a joke!

  • Titlul e si nu e exagerat. E clar ca nu e vina celor de la stagiipebune, ei pot doar sa-ti faca legatura cu companiile, nu le pot impune cum sa se poarte.

    Dar problema nu e numai la nivelul HR-ului, ci si a managerilor si a celor de la interviul tehnic. Despre campaniile de recrutare ale unora din companiile respective auzisem numai de bine. Se pare insa ca daca esti un student care vine pentru un stagiu isi uita brusc bunele obiceiuri. Eu inteleg ca nu esti la fel de important ca un inginer care poate produce ceva pentru companie in cateva zile/saptamani, dar asta nu inseamna ca trebuie sa faci ce vor ei mai degraba decat ce vrei tu (si nu vorbesc aici de faptul ca iti dau de facut sarcini neinteresante, ci de faptul ca te trimit la produs masini cand tu ai vrut sa faci trenuri – asta ca sa nu dam indicii despre companii :D).

    Politica asta nu are cum sa nu se reflecte asupra sitului: studentii care vin din urma vor afla cum esti tratat(a) daca vii la stagiu si vor prefera sa se prezinte la interviu ca un potential angajat pe termen lung (cum am facut si eu),

  • mai intai iti multumim pentru feedback, ne pare rau ca nu l-am vazut mai demult. te rog sa-mi trimiti un mail cu numele companiilor care consideri ca nu te-au tratat corect.

    de anul acesta vom implementa un sistem de feedback online astfel incat studentii sa poata recompensa companiile care ii trateaza corect.

    in final voiam sa-ti mai zic doar ca mi se pare un comentariu cam dur, tinand cont ca te-ai bazat doar pe 2 interviuri (trecute totusi) si deloc pe experienta avuta ca stagiar

    multumesc inca o data pentru feedback!

Lasă un răspuns

Adresa ta de email nu va fi publicată. Câmpurile obligatorii sunt marcate cu *

Acest site folosește Akismet pentru a reduce spamul. Află cum sunt procesate datele comentariilor tale.